| Thread Review for POLL: Can Martine McCutcheon sing? (newest post first) |
|
Andrew Grant |
Posted on 8:20 am on Mar. 30, 2002 |
| After speaking to a friend of mine (who has just met the cast) I will now withdraw all criticisms I have of Joanna Riding & Martine McCutcheon! They are both great at what they do! |
| |
|
Andrew Grant |
Posted on 11:43 am on Mar. 29, 2002 |
| What??
|
| |
|
nicol |
Posted on 2:30 pm on Mar. 23, 2002 |
Andrew, if you want to wage a personal vendetta against Chris or any other poster, would you have the decency to take it up with them privately via messenger.
Please don't (m)acerbate in public. It's not nice.
|
| |
|
Andrew Grant |
Posted on 9:50 am on Mar. 23, 2002 |
I have not been on this site for ages! I have only just seen this and think it very witty for someone to do such a pathetic thing!!
Andy G is in da house!!! (PS Chrisball you are obsessed!)
|
| |
|
chrisball |
Posted on 5:15 am on Mar. 17, 2002 |
| You'd have to ask Michael, Zoe or Uncle Johnny . . . ;-)
|
| |
|
Josh |
Posted on 5:25 pm on Mar. 16, 2002 |
Can Martine sing? Yes. But I don't think she's best suited to musical theatre.
Chris MC Ball. Are you any relation to Michael? Or even Zoe?
|
| |
|
chrisball |
Posted on 8:09 am on Mar. 16, 2002 |
Well I do know about things like that, and the fact is that anything sub-standard would not make it through. The differences between a studio and a theatre are incredible. Acoustically, you will never replicate the real sound of a theatre irrespective of the plug-ins that you use to enhance the recording. You can do anything to improve a recording (just look at half of the pop acts who can't sing . . . bitter irony . . . ;-) )
A recording can be anything you want it to be, so I would argue that the difference was caused by you being "in the moment". A combination of a good voice, some steady acting, a receptive audience and a good sound technician in the theatre can result in the perfect moment. ("This is my moment, this is my perfect moment . . . " Wasn't that a lyric from somewhere?)
Anyway. MC Ball is in da house.
All the best,
Chris
|
| |
|
Jo C |
Posted on 2:13 pm on Mar. 13, 2002 |
Lucy please don't apologise, I know exactly what you mean and I agree with you. I think her Show Me was lovely when I saw her on stage. However when I fist listened to her version of it on the CD, it didn't sound half as strong as when she was singing it live.
Probably just a bad day in the recording studio, but I don't really know much about things like that.
|
| |
|
Lucy |
Posted on 1:42 pm on Mar. 13, 2002 |
Maybe we have different versions but I disagree. I thought show me was the song that she really took off in. Remember musicals are as much about acting as singing and I honestly believe that in that song she really caught the essence of the lyrics!
Sorry.
|
| |
|
Laurence |
Posted on 7:04 am on Mar. 13, 2002 |
| Martine has a lovely voice and sang brilliantly in My Fair Lady
|
| |
|
Jo T |
Posted on 4:01 am on Mar. 13, 2002 |
| I'm sorry, I'm not convinced. I never saw her, but the CD makes me cringe! I think perhaps if it had all been in a slightly lower key... things may have been... different!
|
| |
|
mmebahorel |
Posted on 5:07 pm on Mar. 12, 2002 |
Well, *I* can sing -- that doesn't mean you want to hear me do it. The question should be "Can Martine McCutcheon sing *well*?"
And I honestly never saw her and I don't have the CD, so I'm not voting -- just picking on Chris *g*.
|
| |
|
Jo C |
Posted on 4:53 pm on Mar. 12, 2002 |
YES!
(although I think Show Me was possibly a weak moment-on the CD at least-I thought she sang beautifully in the show.)
|
| |
|
nicol |
Posted on 2:38 pm on Mar. 12, 2002 |
| YES
|
| |
|
Lucy |
Posted on 1:40 pm on Mar. 12, 2002 |
| YES
|
| |
|
chrisball |
Posted on 4:48 am on Mar. 12, 2002 |
| My vote is a resounding YES.
|
| |
Replying to post in